At the COP28 summit, Sultan Al Jaber, COP28 President and CEO of UAE state oil company Adnoc, sparked controversy by claiming a fossil fuel phase-out lacks scientific support. He added that without fossil fuels society would regress to “cave” living. This assertion stands in stark contrast to the scientific community’s consensus. The UN Secretary-General and numerous climate experts have advocated for an urgent reduction in carbon emissions. Studies show a 100% renewable energy system is attainable by 2050, potentially at a lower cost than fossil fuels. COP28 already was overshadowed by the UAE’s alleged oil deal discussions, adding to the tension between climate goals and economic interests.
- Sultan Al Jaber’s claim at COP28 that a fossil fuel phase-out lacks scientific support contradicts consensus on climate action.
- Scientific evidence supports a viable transition to 100% renewable energy by 2050, challenging fossil fuel dependence.
- COP28 faces scrutiny over conflicts of interest, hindering progress towards a sustainable, fossil fuel-free future.
Confronting the cave narrative
The remarks made by Sultan Al Jaber at the COP28 summit have ignited a fierce debate on the future of energy and the viability of a world without reliance on fossil fuels. His statement, suggesting the absence of scientific evidence to phase out fossil fuels, has been met with widespread criticism from the scientific community and stands in sharp contrast to the latest research and technological advancements.
Contrary to Al Jaber’s claims, historical evidence and modern scientific consensus indicate that human progress is not intrinsically tied to fossil fuel consumption. The ancient Romans, known for their advanced engineering and societal structures, thrived without the widespread use of coal, oil, and gas. Moreover, today’s scientific understanding makes it clear that a future without fossil fuels is not only feasible but necessary to mitigate climate change and its devastating impacts.
Renewables: A viable alternative
Researchers from leading institutions have found that a complete transition to renewable energy is possible by or before 2050, with solar and wind energy as the cornerstones. This transition is not only technically achievable but also economically favourable, debunking the myth that a move away from fossil fuels would hinder development or lead to financial instability.
The economic implications of such a shift are particularly relevant for oil-reliant economies. However, with renewables becoming cheaper than fossil fuels, the emphasis has shifted to overcoming infrastructure, storage, and scaling challenges. These hurdles are surmountable with international collaboration and the development of economic frameworks to support the transition, thus preventing disproportionate economic hardship.
Conflicts of interest at COP28
Al Jaber’s dual role as the UAE’s Minister of Industry and Advanced Technology and CEO of the Abu Dhabi National Oil Company has been widely criticised. The potential conflict of interest casts a shadow over his ability to lead COP28 toward meaningful climate action. The UAE has even been accused of using the summit to negotiate oil and gas deals, a move that contradicts the very purpose of the conference.
Technological advances and economic shifts
Advancements in energy storage, such as the decrease in utility-scale battery storage costs by 70% between 2015 and 2018, are paving the way for a renewable-dependent future. Such technologies are not only becoming more accessible but also increasingly cost-effective, further cementing the viability of a fossil fuel-free society.
The transition to abundant, renewable energy promises to transform society in numerous ways, from water desalination and food production to healthcare and education. The economic shifts resulting from this transition could lead to booms in various industries and a reduction in inequality both within and between nations. However, this future requires responsible management to prevent overconsumption and wastage
Currently the top 1% of global emitters, often residing in the wealthiest nations, are responsible for a significant proportion of CO2 emissions. This disparity underscores the importance of equitable transition strategies that do not penalise those who have contributed the least to climate change yet are often the most affected by its consequences.
The road ahead
The science is unequivocal: to limit global warming to 1.5°C, rapid reduction in carbon emissions and a phase-out of fossil fuels are imperative. A widespread scientific agreement holds that a renewable energy system is within reach, challenging the narrative presented by Al Jaber and highlighting the potential for a prosperous future unshackled from oil.
As the COP28 summit progresses, the world’s attention is on the United Arab Emirates to facilitate a transition that aligns with the scientific imperative of phasing out fossil fuels. Whether the summit will overcome the apparent contradictions in its leadership to deliver tangible and effective climate action remains a critical question. The answer will have profound implications for our collective future and the avoidance of an environmental regression that could, ironically, take us back to the proverbial caves.
